HomeServicesTechnical PeopleNova AIClients & resultsPricingInsightsContactBook a 20-minute Nova demo

Home  /  Insights  /  Fabrication

Fabrication

Checking Mill Certificates Against the Client Specification

How to check material certificates against a client specification: certificate type, traceability, chemistry, mechanical and impact results, and missing data.

By Scotia PEP29 October 20265 min read

A material certificate is only useful if somebody has compared it with what the client actually asked for. Done carelessly, the check is a glance at the grade. Done properly, it is a short, repeatable list, and the most important rule on that list is that missing evidence is never a pass.

Start with what the specification requires

Before opening the certificate, list what the specification demands: the grade and standard, the delivery condition, the certificate type, chemistry limits, mechanical properties, impact test temperature and values, and any extra limits such as carbon equivalent or hardness. A written list stops the check drifting towards whatever the certificate happens to show.

Check the certificate type

Specifications often ask for an inspection certificate to EN 10204. A type 3.1 certificate is issued by the manufacturer’s authorised inspection representative, who is independent of the manufacturing department. A type 3.2 certificate is also validated by the purchaser’s representative or a third party. A type 2.1 or 2.2 declaration does not report test results from the delivered product. Make sure the certificate you hold is at least the level the specification asks for.

Trace it to the material

  • The heat number on the certificate matches the heat number marked on the material.
  • The size, thickness and quantity on the certificate cover what was delivered.
  • One certificate may cover several heats. Check each heat you are using, not just the first.

Compare the chemistry, element by element

Check every element the specification limits against its minimum and maximum. Note whether the certificate reports the heat (ladle) analysis or a product analysis, because specifications can set different limits for each. A value reported as “<0.005” against a minimum cannot show that the minimum is met.

Recalculate the carbon equivalent

Where the specification limits carbon equivalent, calculate it from the reported chemistry rather than relying on the printed figure. The IIW formula is CE = C + Mn/6 + (Cr + Mo + V)/5 + (Ni + Cu)/15. If your calculated value and the printed value disagree, find out why before accepting the material.

Compare the mechanical properties

  • Yield or proof strength, tensile strength and elongation against the minimum, and the maximum where one is set.
  • The limits that apply to this thickness: many specifications change requirements by thickness band.
  • Units: MPa and N/mm² are equal, but ksi and psi need converting before you compare.
  • Hardness on the scale the specification names. Values on a different scale are not comparable without a recognised conversion.

Check the impact results

The test must have been carried out at the specification temperature or colder. Check both the average and the individual minimum values. Check the specimen size too: sub-size specimens normally carry reduced requirements, so look at which table in the specification applies before judging the result.

Treat missing data as unconfirmed, not as a pass

If the certificate does not report a required value, the result is not “pass”. Mark it as cannot confirm, chase the supplier and keep the material on hold until it is resolved. A certificate that looks complete but silently omits a required test is a common way for non-conforming material to reach the shop floor.

Record the result

For each requirement, record the specification value, the certificate value and the outcome: pass, fail or cannot confirm. Sign it off against the heat number. When a client or auditor asks months later, that record is the evidence.

Where Nova fits

Nova’s Material Certification check reads the certificate and the client specification, then compares each requirement in code. Anything it cannot confirm is marked as such for an engineer to resolve, rather than guessed. The reading is checked by the engineer, and the pass and fail decisions follow the specification you provide.

Conclusion

A good certificate check is boring on purpose: the same list, every time, with “cannot confirm” allowed as an answer. It costs a few minutes per heat and prevents the expensive conversation after the material has been cut.

#material certificates#quality#traceability#compliance
Get started

Want this applied to your programme?

Tell us about the package or programme you need to deliver and we will tell you where the early warning signs are.

Book a 20-minute Nova demo